When I think about Modern:Primitive, I go straight back to the studio at the farm near Romney Marsh. Windows on three sides, a 32-channel Mackie desk, racks of outboard and the morning sun flooding the room. In winter I’d chop some wood and get the stove going and my older, and least responsible dog, Spears, would occasionally jump onto my lap and sit directly in front of my face, which did very little for productivity.
It was a great place to make a record. My other life involved nightclubs, powerful sound systems and the latest technology, while at home the internet ranged from dreadful to non-existent and there were five acres of garden and a home built in 1480 to look after. The album’s title had a fairly literal meaning.
Twenty years on, I’ve been listening again to an album whose release became a spectacular mess. In the week it was due out in 2006, the distributor went bust and every physical copy was impounded and then months later, I paid £1 a copy to buy back my own stock, which was as expensive as it was humiliating. A second distributor went under three days before the rearranged release in early 2007, but by then, the promotional work had been wasted and I’d had enough. The remaining copies were destroyed and it quickly became the third artist album I’d released in the past 5 years that had to be filed under ‘painful learning experience’.
For years, that was the story I associated with the record, but listening now, I find myself more interested in what I was trying to make, and where I lost my nerve.
Modern:Primitive was my second Elite Force artist album, following No Turning Back. I’d cut back on DJing and Strongarm Sessions broadcasts to give it room, and I wanted to explore some of the music that wasn’t finding its way into the singles. There was house, techno, electro and breaks in there, but also downbeat music and songs that needed more of me than a useful club record did.
‘You’ was one of those songs, built around a simple guitar sample and a soaring chorus. I remember playing it at a packed show in Tbilisi after someone requested it and I really wasn’t convinced it belonged in the set - or any DJ set, come to that. Then people started singing along. For all the time I’d spent worrying about what would work on a dance floor, I hadn’t anticipated that a track like that would get such a positive reaction. It was a moment that was cathartic, unusual but thoroughly compelling. And I never played it out again.
‘Fly Me Into the Ocean’ is another I still put on for my own pleasure. I can hear the freedom in it, although at seven minutes and sixteen seconds I do now wonder whether I could have said the same thing in four. Years of making records for DJs had left me with some fairly ingrained habits.
There are things I’d change - I wonder whether I should have followed the songwriting further, or put a small live band together to take the music out into the world… but DJing was my promotional engine, and I’d made an album that reached well beyond what I could comfortably present in a DJ set.
Coming back to it now, Modern:Primitive feels closer to a Simon Shackleton album than an Elite Force one. I can hear ideas I eventually felt able to follow more fully on The Shadowmaker, released in 2025, and places where I was still negotiating with my own expectations. I’d make a different record today, but I recognise the person who was trying to make this one.
I’ve written more about the album, the farm and the awkward business of growing beyond an artist name over on Substack.